After some solo success (Bobby Brown) and Bell Biv DeVoe, all the members of New Edition reunited for 1996's Home Again. And we see you, Johnny Gill—the rebel without a baseball cap!

Getty Images

How are we suppose to pick just one?

Sydney Scott
Jan, 26, 2017

During their visit to the ESSENCE office, we got the cast of BET's The New Edition Story to help us settle a long-standing debate over the best New Edition song. While the debate still rages on in the office, the guys did reveal which of the beloved R&B group's songs they love.

For Bryshere Y. Gray, who plays Michael Bivens, "Candy Girl" is a solid choice. Keith Powers and Luke James, aka Ronnie DeVoe and Johnny Gill, respectively, picked "Can You Stand The Rain." Woody McClain, who portrays Bobby Brown, went with "You're Not My Kind Of Girl." And, Elijah Kelley, aka Ricky Bell, opted for "If It Isn't Love."

Subscribe to our daily newsletter for the latest in hair, beauty, style and celebrity news.

Still, we can't pick just one and even with the guys' in-put we're still not sure we can choose a favorite. Help us out, which New Edition song do you love the most?