With the best eyebrow pencils on the market, you can create hairlike strokes that look like the real thing. That’s because these instruments feature a fine tip that’s ideal for drawing thin lines and filling in sparse areas. Not to mention most come with a spoolie brush to help you comb the product through your brows, which is a key to make them look more natural. Another factor that separates the superior options from run-of-the-mill alternatives, is the formula: Some brow pencils boast up to 24 hours of wear, conditioning ingredients and a rich color payoff like our top pick from Benefit Cosmetics.
Ahead we break down the best eyebrow pencils on the market—all of which we’ve reviewed in the areas of performance, value and quality. When it comes to defining your brows, these are the best tools for the job.
01
01
A Top-Rated Option That’s Easy To Use
Benefit Cosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer
This waterproof pencil—available in 12 shades—has an ultra-fine tip that makes drawing hairlike strokes easier than it sounds. It also comes with a durable spoolie that diffuses harsh lines, creating a natural-looking finish.
Make Up For Ever Aqua Resist Waterproof Eyebrow Definer Pencil
For a formula that won’t budge when exposed to sweat or moisture, look no further than this top-rated brow definer that boasts transfer-proof color and 24 hours of water-proof wear.
Here’s a product that won’t leave your brows crunchy. It’s infused with jojoba seed oil—a nourishing ingredient that lends itself to the formula’s creamy consistency—to keep your brows in tip top shape.
One of the most iconic products for defining your brows is this ultra-thin pencil from Anastasia Beverly Hills. It has a fine tip that makes it easy to fill in sparse areas and it glides on smoothly—no skipping or tugging.
The mechanics of the luxurious brow pencil is worth underscoring: It features a grooming brush, a built-in sharpener and a refillable barrel. More good news: One refill cartridge is included so you’re technically getting two brow pencils in one.
This liquid brow pen has a felt tip that allows you to create wildly realistic looking brow hair (think: a microblade effect without the redness).The formula is long-wearing, smudge-resistant and available in three shades.
On one end of the tool, you’ll find a brow pencil, and on the opposite side, a brow gel and spoolie to keep them in place. Keep in mind that this formula is waterproof, so it offers twice as much staying power.
Too Faced Pomade In A Pencil Eyebrow Shaper And Filler
For a bold brows, consider this option from Too Faced. It’s essentially a waterproof pomade (in pencil form), so you can create dramatic, high-definition brows that wont move.
