Fall’s hottest makeup palettes are all hitting shelves now, and one of the hottest of the bunch is Lancome’s limited edition Eye Brightening All-In-One 5 Shadow & Liner Palette in Teal Fury.

The compact comes stocked with five of the hottest aqua and turquoise shades we’ve ever seen — so, naturally, we had to take the blue hues on a test run!

Here, five ESSENCE.COM staffers with different skin tones try the chic shadow on for size. Check out their reviews, here!