Skip to content
  • Essence GU
  • Beautycon
  • NaturallyCurly
  • Afropunk
  • Essence Studios
  • Soko Mrkt
  • Ese Funds
  • Refinery29
  • WeLoveUs.shop
  • 2026 ESSENCE Festival Of Culture
  • Celebrity
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Lifestyle
  • Entrepreneurship
  • News
  • Shopping
  • Video
  • Events
  • Subscribe
Home • News

An Education On Slavery And Why Ben Carson Was Dead Wrong  

On Monday the surgeon turned legislator claimed that slaves were the same as free-willed immigrants.
An Education On Slavery And Why Ben Carson Was Dead Wrong
Mark Wilson/ 2015 Getty Images
By Danielle Kwateng-Clark · Updated October 26, 2020
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready…
5239116055001

It’s sad that we’ve come to this place. But apparently an explanation of slavery is needed for our new Housing and Urban Development Secretary, Ben Carson.

On Monday while speaking to his department employees, the Yale graduating neurosurgeon jumped on stage and made a statement that left the world confused. 

“That’s what America is about, a land of dreams and opportunity,” Carson said about immigration. “There were other immigrants who came here in the bottom of slave ships, worked even longer, even harder for less. But they too had a dream that one day their sons, daughters, grandsons, granddaughters, great-grandsons, great-granddaughters, might pursue prosperity and happiness in this land.”

Black Twitter immediately got into formation. 

https://twitter.com/quintabrunson/status/838933216178270208

 

"Roots" according to Ben Carson: Kunta Kinte came to America for the job opportunities and freedom. #bencarson

— A Mind is a Terrible Thing (@dp270) March 7, 2017

 

https://twitter.com/12jarod87/status/838978201225474048

 

The Black delegation hereby trades Ben Carson for:__________
(anybody)!!!!!#SlavesAreNotImmigrants

— Eric Guster, Esq (@EricGuster) March 7, 2017

Some even tried to explain the different perspectives between actual African immigrants and African-Americans that have had a completely different experience.

As the child of a West African immigrant & US descendant of slaves, I can't stress how wrong Ben Carson is to imply the two are the same.

— Nadra Nittle (@NadraKareem) March 6, 2017

 

Slavery was not immigration. It was abduction. @RealBenCarson’s intellectual dishonesty knows no bounds, it seems. https://t.co/YFSosnd1tE

— Jamil Smith جميل كريم (@JamilSmith) March 6, 2017

 

https://twitter.com/angryblackhoemo/status/838911939891822594

 

Isn't it funny how Ben Carson, a brain surgeon, seems to lack the very thing that his career is based on.

— Antoinette (@Llaaves) March 6, 2017

 

Ben Carson: Slaves were immigrants who came to America to reach their dreams

Ben Carson's great-grandmother: pic.twitter.com/6uuqxoCWCU

— MBGOTW (@_fortheloveofAj) March 6, 2017

 

Even the New York Daily News called Carson out. 

NY Daily News' front page tomorrow: pic.twitter.com/u3ZPycbyWC

— philip lewis (@Phil_Lewis_) March 7, 2017

Slavery, in regards to trans-Atlantic trade to the Americas, started sometime around the 1600s. Anthony Johnson from Angola is said to be the first freed slave who served in the Colony of Virginia. But the three centuries of slavery predominantly from West Africa brought millions of human beings from the Motherland to North, Central and South America, as well as the Caribbean. 

Black bodies used as work exports is not a myth. It’s not a joke. It wasn’t humane or for fair trade. And it, for certain, was not of their own volition. 

To imply that these beyond-resilient Africans had a choice, and that that choice was to serve others and be subjected to death-like circumstances that reflect in systematic oppression to this day, is incredibly wrong. 

And the saddest part, is that Ben Carson himself is a direct descendant of Southern slaves with his parents coming from “large families in rural Georgia”.

This morning, Carson and his wife issued a joint statement stemming from the outrage. “We should revel in the fact that although we got here through different routes, we have many things in common now that should unite us in our mission to have a land where there is liberty and justice for all,” it reads. 

The statement is a hard pill to swallow. First, he does not apologize or use this moment to educate others (although he’s the one who needs the history lesson). But most alarming, he thinks African-Americans should “revel” in a tragic history that’s led to oppression in present day. 

Hopefully Carson delves deeper into slavery and in the research he discovers who he is, in context to the generations of ancestors whose real “dream” was for us to be smarter than those who oppress us. 

TOPICS:  Black Twitter