Skip to content
  • Essence GU
  • Beautycon
  • NaturallyCurly
  • Afropunk
  • Essence Studios
  • Soko Mrkt
  • Ese Funds
  • Refinery29
  • WeLoveUs.shop
  • 2026 ESSENCE Festival Of Culture
  • Celebrity
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Lifestyle
  • Entrepreneurship
  • News
  • Shopping
  • Video
  • Events
  • Subscribe
Home • Beauty

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market

A perfectly beat face is just a few strokes away! 
Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
Yuri Arcurs/Getty images
By Samantha Callender · Updated October 26, 2020
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready…

Lips are the first thing that comes to mind when we mention makeup pencils. Those as beauty trends change and application methods because easier, there are many makeup products that are taking the pencil form.  

5196832647001

Many companies are opting to put their formulas for concealer, primer, and even highlighters into a pencil to give you better control over application and precision. Whether you’re a beginner or a pro, we’ve found some of the best products in pencil form for your to give a try to create your perfect, everyday glam look.  

01
Pencil Them In

This creamy eyeshadow goes on with rich pigments and a hint of shimmer.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at kmart.com $6.79 Shop!
02
Pencil Them In

24 A classic nude color from a classic brand that glides on smoothly and lasts throughout the day.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at macys.com $24 Shop!
03
Pencil Them In

This deep hue makes for an excellent vampy lip, or can be used to create a cool ombre look with a softer color.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at gerardcosmetics.com $16 Shop!
04
Pencil Them In

Use this pencil to highlight your brow bone and other areas of your eye to make your eyeshadow and eye color pop!

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at sephora.com $23 Shop!
05
Pencil Them In

With it’s creamy matte formula, this pencil covers dark spots and illuminates places like the cheeks, inner eye, and brow bone.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at bobbibrowncosmetics.com $32 Shop!
06
Pencil Them In

This pencil does more than line your lips a pretty cherry color- its a stain that you can use to add a bit of rouge to your look.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at amazon.com $34.99 Shop!
07
Pencil Them In

A gorgeous blend between brown and red, this sultry color compliments any skin tone. It goes on smooth and lasts all day

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at makeupforever.com $18 Shop!
08
Pencil Them In

This bold coral will give your lips a nice color for spring. Use this in addition to a lipstick or lipgloss.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at nordstrom.com $17.50 Shop!
09
Pencil Them In

A silky formula that goes on smooth, the pretty mauve is a perfect pastel hue.  

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at laurageller.com $8 Shop!
10
Pencil Them In

If liquid liner just isn’t your thing, stick to the classics with this black liner that is perfect for use around the waterline.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at jet.com $7.97 Shop!
11
Pencil Them In

Meant to brighten the eyes, use this pencil along your waterline to make your eyes appear bigger and more bold.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at net-a-porter.com $26 Shop!
12
Pencil Them In

A pop of green will make your pout pretty and bold this spring. The pigmented pencil goes on smoothly and is long lasting.  

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at kaoir.com $17.99 Shop!
13
Pencil Them In

With a hint of shimmer, this lip stain stays in place all day and delivers a high shine stain that comes in an array of colors

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at tartecosmetics.com $10 Shop!
14
Pencil Them In

The velvety smooth sticks allow you to perfectly control where you apply your contour. Coming in an array of light and dark shades, you can create the perfect contour with these easy to control sticks.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at sephora.com $45 Shop!
15
Pencil Them In

With a vast selection of cosmetic products, Shea Moisture’s eye pencil delivers bold pigments in several colorful shades. Use this along the waterline or around the eye for a pop of color.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at target.com $7.99 Shop!
16
Pencil Them In

A jumbo concealer pencil is perfect to spot conceal those tricky areas underneath the eye. They come in a range of shades so you’re bound to find your perfect match.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at nyxcosmetics.com $7 Shop!
17
Pencil Them In

This perfectly pink color adds a touch of springtime fresh to your makeup look. The satin finish leaves your lips feeling soft and smooth.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at sephora.com $27 Shop!
18
Pencil Them In

If you’re still in the beginning stages of learning to use liner, this gel-in-a-pencil is perfect to practice mastering those lines and wings.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at target.com $6.99 Shop!
19
Pencil Them In

This pencil is excellent for defining brows and making them look natural. This pencil also comes with a brow gel to hold the product in place.  

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at sephora.com $25 Shop!
20
Pencil Them In

Use this multipurpose pencil to prime eyes, lips, or face in one swift stroke. The pencil is infused with oils that moisturize the skin before you apply product.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at sephora.com $18 Shop!
21
Pencil Them In

This drugstore staple defines brows, and comes with a built in spoolie brush so you can brush them into place.

Pencil Them In! The Best Pencil Makeup Products On The Market
available at walgreens.com $2.19 Shop!
TOPICS:  Shopping