Essence.com

Home » Fashion & Beauty » Commentary

 

Are Successful Black Women Obligated to Reproduce?


birthcontrol-400x200v3.jpg
By Demetria L. Lucas

A curious idea was posed to me, and by extension, all Black woman like me. A woman, Dominique (not her real name), suggested that it was my duty as an educated, sensible, African-American woman to get married and procreate.

What?!

Her idea in a nutshell:

Back in the day, WEB Dubois proclaimed that we need to rely on the "Talented Tenth" to move us forward as a community. I would argue that the so- called Talented Tenth is failing our community. We are no longer getting married- or believing in marriage- and we are no longer reproducing (at the rate of other folks in the community).

The people in our community that need to produce the most are not and the people who need to stop producing, multiply like there is no tomorrow. What will happen to future generations?? We complain that there is a lack (in particular) of well mannered, educated AA men. But if we are not getting married and having babies and in turn, raising well-mannered, educated AA men, who is to blame?

Maybe we should re-think our position on not having children. We need more future [offspring like us] than not.

This idea is the result of Dominique's BFF's most recent visit to the Ob/Gyn in which her doctor, a white woman, "begged" her to start multiplying. The Ob/Gyn hoped not to offend, then told her patient that more educated, professional AA's need to start having babies and need to start having them soon, to balance out the craziness in the Black community. What, the doctor wondered, would become of African- Americans if all of the educated folks continue to be baby free?

Uh... I resent the idea of being told what to do with my time and my body by anyone, and that includes my gynecologist (unless it's a health concern.) I don't need my own kid to know that having a child isn't like buying a car or a house that you can sell when you're tired of it. Raising a child is a monumental responsibility (time, emotion, finance, etc.) and should only be done when and if you are ready- that goes for Black professionals and anybody else too.

And two, I'm not so keen on the idea of popping out a baby without a husband just to benefit the race. I also don't like the additional pressure on women to reproduce. I think we all get that enough once we hit about 25 (or 30 if you're in the NorthEast.)

Also, doesn't this idea wreak of elitism and classism? Isn't all very "stop 'them' from taking over us?" I mean, we're talking about ideas from the 1900s!! - literally. DuBois's original article about the Talented Tenth was published in 1903.
I thought the masses would see things my way and this was some fringe thought of one wacky doctor and an otherwise sensible woman who'd bought into the idea... until I started talking to people who agreed with both of them. My best friend, Tariq, a single Black professional with no children in D.C., was the first unlikely soul to hop aboard.

He said:
I can agree with that [idea] It's our duty to continue the legacy, so our kids can have something. It's how you build old money. We can counteract all the "'Shika's" and "Tanya's" kids who are the first in the family to go to school. We can build continuity by having kids, it uplifts our "race."

Another single, Black professional female, not only co-signed the idea but pointed me to a blog post, "1984 and More: Spreading (the right) Seeds" by VerySmartBrothas which harshly endorsed the idea as well.

In summary it read:
My mom lamented the fact that neither I nor any of my close friends have any children yet, but these fertile hoodrats are popping out kids by the bushel. How will Black America prosper if people like you (educated, no record or missing teeth) are waiting longer and longer to maybe get married and maybe have one child while D-Block and Chardonnay are producing a new seed every 14 months?

...If this trend continues, we (the very smart Brothas and Sistas) will make ourselves extinct, or at least so overrun by swarms of oddly-named hood spawn that extinction wouldn't seem like such a bad idea.

Educated, sensible ladies, do we have an obligation to the race to find husbands and reproduce? Or is this idea just plain nuts?

Read more from Demetria at www.abelleinbrooklyn.com and follow her on twitter @abelleinbk.

 

Next Story | Beyonce and Keri Hilson Lead Soul Train Nominations »

Comments | Post a comment now »
 

The problem with Original women that have been colonized is that they no longer understand what it is to be a women. They don't understand the purpose or the role of woman. Apparently we are walking around with breasts for decoration or to bait men. Haha! Our reproductive organs are not for reproduction, but instead just spare parts that we alter at our leisure. Until Original women return to their true selves, men need to boycott. Stop impregnating these women.

 

Contrary to popular belief, a college degree does not make one "educated". There are plenty of uneducated college graduates walking the planet. We need more REAL women on the planet. Procreation is not a question for them, but a duty. Only REAL men and women with the knowledge of themselves can restore order. Those chasing money, "success" and false gods are doing the community as disservice by continuing to perpetuate this cycle. Know yourself and understand what is REAL before attempting to bring children into the world.


 

There are some interesting, and valid points in this article. However, instead of putting the pressure on black professionals to procreate, and increase our "elite" numbers, why don't we start working in our communities to uplift the rest of our people?
To me, this notion of procreating among black professionals for the sake of creating more sounds really classist, and elitist.

We need to get back to basics (supporting our community, and giving the knowledge and skills we already possess to youth in need).

Let's focus on the people that are here now, instead of those someone else wants us to create. There is much work to be done yet! Our sense of community and responsibility has been lost in the rat race of me, myself, and I.

 

littering chooses abscess:Tito wrongs subdirectories programmability:

 

I actually agree with the premise of this article. In fact I have thought it many times before but thought it was too crazy to say out loud. However, I agree with Ingrid, by the time we have finished our education and established our career there may not be much time left for children. I just had my first child at 31 and think I may stop at two.

 

pls and pls there are enough black professionals out there.might not be in united state...but i tell ya go to places like Nigerian universities and work places ,as well as other countries in Africa at large.please try something new...date them and enjoy your life.Also, remember to respect them as husband.They are very smart,aggressive,cool,well mannered and classy...and could be weird at times.please,explore the Africa you dont know.thanks .and stop complaining.

 

I have to say that I am one-hundred percent in agreement with the author of this article. Not because I believe that highly educated and successful African American women shouldn't reproduce, in fact I believe they should. However, I believe that as Lucas pointed out: raising children can be a monumental responsibility...one that women shouldn't have to go at alone. No woman wants to answer the dreaded question of: mommy where's daddy? So to counteract that response, I believe that highly educated and successful Black women should exercise wisdom when choosing to raise a child. What wiser decision can a successful AA woman make than choosing to raise a child who has a healthy relationship with both their mother as well as their father.

 

Women must redefine what it means to be a woman. So many women have fallen for the idea that a woman must be married and have children in order to be considered a part of the human species. Not so! It's up to us to define what it means to be a woman, not the patriarchal or matriarchal society at large. Unmarried African American women don't have to prove to the world why they aren't married. The reality as to why many of them aren't married is revealed for the world to see on a daily basis. Look around your communities!

 

It is your right not procreate, but is not your right to judge others and call them ugly names...I think a big round belly filled with life is an amazing thing!! Time brings about a chnage in everything and everybody.I pray that one daythese so called black professionals without extentions of them
will the error of their ways , and do the right thing and love someone back.

 

There are two reasons why I think successful black people of today are not settling down and having children. The first is that there are not enough Black male professionals for the professional black women to settle down with. Being a black female in Law School I see it especially. Black men make up only 1% of the profession. I think numbers wise, there is a disproportionate number of black female professionals to black male. Majority of those women would most likely not settle for having children without a father.
The second relates to their parents instilling education first, then all else second. It's funny how many times I've heard, "go get an education and the money first, then think about a man and family" but by the time that happens, there may not be many men around. It may also lead black women to feel bitter because they did what they were told but now are not able to get their promised man. If we follow the advice of our parents, there is a narrow window between graduation and meet someone, get married, have kids. Compile that with the lack of eligible men, it just becomes difficult to even start the process of marriage, let alone have kids. While I want to continue the black middle/upper class legacy as stated above, I think those are the major things holding us back.
The solution may be to focus spreading the benefits and joys of marriage (through books, church forums, speaker series, magazine articles, ect.) to those single successful Black men out there and encouraging them to mentor younger men so that the next generation of Black women will have Black men to settle down with. Just a thought.

 

There are two reasons why I think successful black people of today are not settling down and having children. The first is that there are not enough Black male professionals for the professional black women to settle down with. Being a black female in Law School I see it especially. Black men make up only 1% of the profession. I think numbers wise, there is a disproportionate number of black female professionals to black male. Majority of those women would most likely not settle for having children without a father.
The second relates to their parents instilling education first, then all else second. It's funny how many times I've heard, "go get an education and the money first, then think about a man and family" but by the time that happens, there may not be many men around. It may also lead black women to feel bitter because they did what they were told but now are not able to get their promised man. If we follow the advice of our parents, there is a narrow window between graduation and meet someone, get married, have kids. Compile that with the lack of eligible men, it just becomes difficult to even start the process of marriage, let alone have kids. While I want to continue the black middle/upper class legacy as stated above, I think those are the major things holding us back.
The solution may be to focus spreading the benefits and joys of marriage (through books, church forums, speaker series, magazine articles, ect.) to those single successful Black men out there and encouraging them to mentor younger men so that the next generation of Black women will have Black men to settle down with. Just a thought.

 

I don't have an obligation or a responsibility to find no one or reproduce, that is a choice bestowed upon me and me only. It has been my personal choice not to have children as a highly educated black woman. But,it is my responsibility to go back to the black community and be a role model to the young blacks;that's how i have chosen to give back, not by having a bunch of babies that i have no interest in raising. And i would say that that goes for all other successful black people male and female.

Leave Your Comment






     


Customer Service | E-mail Newsletter Sign-up | Try 2 Issues Risk Free | Give a Gift of Essence | Change Your Address | Renew Your Subscription | Pay Your Bill | Questions & Comments

Site Map | Our Company | Media Kit | Press Room | Bios | Writer's Guidelines | Careers | Internships | Essence Cares | Contact Us

© 2009 Essence Communications Inc. All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use